Author Archives:

NCT, For Profit, More Student Loan Messes

Wow, NCT (National Collegiate Trust) just gets messier.

student loan mess
house you can afford if you pay your student loans

The entity, which bought private student loans, made a deal

with the CPFB (Consumer Protection Finance Bureau) last

week, which is being challenged.

Which Entity Owns the Student Loans?

This is the problem NCT has had, and I have successfully defendant some of their student loan lawsuits because they could not prove that the NCT trust (there are over a dozen of them) suing my client, actually owned the student loan that was the subject of the debt.

The suing trust hires a law firm, which can usually produce loan documents signed by my client, but, with a bank, the original student loan lender.

There follows a series of documents and affidavits, which never say that my client’s student loan was in the batch, or, group of batches, of student loans mentioned in the documents.

I say, groups of batches, because I have seen up to 48 different categories of loans in an exhibit to a exhibit of student loans  purchased.

Some judges have accepted this, well, stuff, as sufficient, and ruled against my client.

They top it off with an affidavit from someone who works for TransWorld, which just collects stuff created by other entities.  Allegedly.

Their affidavit says, I deal with these sorts of documents all the time, and these are exactly the sort of documents with which I deal.

An affidavit is supposed to be of personal knowledge, not what someone else told you.  That is hearsay.

Which Entity Made The Student Loan Deal With The CPFB?

This is hard for me to follow, but, from the Shahien Nasiripour Bloomberg story:

In September, the regulator and Florida-based Vantage Capital Group LLC, which controls the National Collegiate trusts, hammered out a settlement by agreeing to a third-party audit of the more than 800,000 loans that have been held by the 15 vehicles. The audit would enable Vantage to find out which loans it can really pursue and which loans it can’t. While the audit proceeds, all payments to investors in securities based on those loans would be placed into escrow. The proposed deal also calls for $19 million in fines and restitution for thousands of borrowers sued by debt collectors.

However, here is where some of these other entities come in.

The 15 vehicles that make up the National Collegiate trusts, along with the loan servicers, insurers, banks, hedge funds, and debt collectors with a stake in its operations, would be required to foot the bill for the audit and settlement—under a deal they didn’t approve. And if the audit reveals widespread wrongdoing, the price tag could climb sharply, according to court papers. Unsurprisingly, they cried foul.

All told, investors holding some $1.4 billion in NCSLT notes asked U.S. District Judge Gregory Sleet in Wilmington, Delaware, to reject the accord, saying Vantage doesn’t have the power to negotiate on their behalf. Loan insurer Ambac Financial Group Inc. and debt collector Transworld Systems Inc. said the deal mandates changes to how trusts operate that would violate decade-old contracts.

OK, I admit.  I don’t get it.

If Vantage controls the NCT entities, how come these other guys get to say anything?

If it does not, how does it get to agree that they fork over $19 million plus of their dollars?

Read the whole thing, I will be following this story.

And contact me if you have NCT, or any, student loan questions.

Student Loan Solution?

So, I have thought for a while that part of the resolution to the student loan crisis was for the government to get out of the business of student loan lending, which has caused tuition costs to skyrocket without any increase in the value of a college degree.  And that part of getting the government… Continue Reading

Student Loan Problems?

For student loan problems, be careful whom you pay. Like many attorneys, I give free consultations. And have a written retainer agreement before I take any money from clients. Game of Loans Full marks to whoever came up with the name for the crackdown on crooked student debt relief providers. Federal and state authorities are… Continue Reading

Student Loan Discharge Cases

Let’s look at a recent student loan discharge case result in bankruptcy court. Disbarred Lawyer? Not the most sympathetic plaintiff, right? First, in order to discharge, get out of, a student loan in bankruptcy court, you have to file a lawsuit against the student loan lender(s).  So, you are the plaintiff. Thanks to friend Bobby… Continue Reading

Student Loan Mess – PSLF

PLSF (Public Service Loan Forgiveness)  started ten years ago, providing forgiveness of the balance of student loans after ten years of payments IF you worked in qualified jobs during those ten years. Who Will Qualify for PSLF? Unfortunately, lots of folks who think they are getting student loans forgiven – will not. From the Jillian… Continue Reading

Is The Government About To Nail NCT?

NCT (National Collegiate Trusts) is a frequent subject of my student loan blog posts. What Is NCT again? NCT is a company, well, 15 separate trusts, that buy (allegedly) private student loans from banks, packages them into trusts that, well, let me quote from the Bloomberg news site article by Shahien Nasiripour: The trusts, created more… Continue Reading

PSLF and More Student Loan News

First, another view of the student loan   debt crisis, then, PSLF.   Donald L. Swanson frames the issue nicely, especially for high endowment schools. He goes through the high, no, astronomical, cost of attending Northwestern, even though its endowment is just shy of ten billion dollars, and will exceed that by 20% if its current… Continue Reading

Student Loan Servicer Abuses

Student Loan Servicer Abuses, another recurring topic. Jillian Bergman on the MarketWatch site: student loan servicers — the companies hired by the federal government to help borrowers manage their debt — create confusion and make paperwork errors that keep borrowers from reaping the program’s benefits.  Well, the incentive is for the servicer to get lenders… Continue Reading

Student Loan News Update

Student Loan servicers will become   student loan servicer under the new proposal by Education Secretary Betsy Devos.  Article in Forbes: In May, DeVos announced that the Education Department would select one servicer to service all federal student loans, which represented a change from the current multiple-servicer system. DeVos outlined four primary reasons: Ensure superior customer… Continue Reading

NCT And Me

Shout out to Susan Tompor of the Detroit Free Press                (click here) for an excellent article on NCT private student loan trusts. With quotes from yours truly. Anyway, the New York Times story I linked to last week is helping publicize the story, that NCT (National Collegiate Trust)… Continue Reading