Author Archives:

Is The Government About To Nail NCT?

NCT (National Collegiate Trusts) is a frequent

NCT in trouble
University of Michigan law school

subject of my student loan blog posts.

What Is NCT again?

NCT is a company, well, 15 separate trusts, that buy (allegedly) private student loans from banks, packages them into trusts

that, well, let me quote from the Bloomberg news site article by Shahien Nasiripour:

The trusts, created more than a decade ago, cumulatively have held well over 874,000 loans made to more than 812,000 people who borrowed money from banks mostly to pay for their higher education, according to filings with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and monthly reports to investors. Those banks sold the loans to a middleman who created the trusts, and the trusts then sold notes promising certain returns to investors ranging from the hedge-fund manager Waterfall Asset Management LLC to the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. Monthly payments to investors are backed by borrowers’ monthly payments on their student loans.

Why Is NCT In Trouble?

Because they cannot prove in court that they own the private student loans on which they are suing.

It is a default judgment business model, they sue betting that you, the consumer-borrower, will not answer.

Then they get a judgment and garnish wages and whatever other forms of execution on a judgment that your state allows.

I have lost some cases defending NCT suits, with judges who accepted their insufficient paperwork.

And some have been dismissed, and some settled for less than half the amount sought in the NCT lawsuit.

As the article puts it:

Consumer lawyers say borrowers generally don’t show up in court, leading to default judgments against them that could eventually lead to wage garnishment. But the lawsuits haven’t led to big recoveries for investors. And in recent years, a number of judges around the U.S. have dismissed the trusts’ lawsuits against borrowers or else ruled against their debt collectors, citing sloppy paperwork.

What Is The Government Doing About NCT?

The CPFB (Consumer Protection Finance Bureau) has been investigating, and the article says there is a tentative settlement.

If it requires NCT to prove it owns a loan before trying to collect from the student loan borrower, or co-signer, that would put them out of business, from what I have seen.

What will the settlement do?

If finalized, it would require the payment of “large sums” in restitution to borrowers and civil penalties to the U.S. government, according to a summary of the proposal filed in a separate court case.

Stay tuned!

UPDATE:

NCT NAILED

PSLF and More Student Loan News

First, another view of the student loan   debt crisis, then, PSLF.   Donald L. Swanson frames the issue nicely, especially for high endowment schools. He goes through the high, no, astronomical, cost of attending Northwestern, even though its endowment is just shy of ten billion dollars, and will exceed that by 20% if its current… Continue Reading

Student Loan Servicer Abuses

Student Loan Servicer Abuses, another recurring topic. Jillian Bergman on the MarketWatch site: student loan servicers — the companies hired by the federal government to help borrowers manage their debt — create confusion and make paperwork errors that keep borrowers from reaping the program’s benefits.  Well, the incentive is for the servicer to get lenders… Continue Reading

Student Loan News Update

Student Loan servicers will become   student loan servicer under the new proposal by Education Secretary Betsy Devos.  Article in Forbes: In May, DeVos announced that the Education Department would select one servicer to service all federal student loans, which represented a change from the current multiple-servicer system. DeVos outlined four primary reasons: Ensure superior customer… Continue Reading

NCT And Me

Shout out to Susan Tompor of the Detroit Free Press                (click here) for an excellent article on NCT private student loan trusts. With quotes from yours truly. Anyway, the New York Times story I linked to last week is helping publicize the story, that NCT (National Collegiate Trust)… Continue Reading

National Collegiate Trust (NCT) Student Loans

New York Attorney General Schneiderman has set his sights on the NCT (National Collegiate Trust) vulture.  Can you find it in the picture? Stacy Cowley in the New York TImes: National Collegiate’s trusts have aggressively pursued in court borrowers who fall behind on their student loan payments. An article this week in The New York… Continue Reading

The Brunner Test

The Brunner test is the big hurdle student loan borrowers must get over to discharge student loan debt in bankruptcy. What Is The Brunner Test? The Brunner case is the bane of consumer bankruptcy lawyers trying to get their client’s student loan debt discharged in bankruptcy. Continue Reading

Student Loan News

I long for the day when I can lead with some good Student Loan News.  Today is not that day. The Seattle Times editorialized on a couple of my recurrent themes. Students from middle-class families are forced to depend too heavily on student loans to pay for college. In Washington, about six out 10 students… Continue Reading

Student Loan Seminar

I was privileged to be part of a panel on student loan issues at the American Bankruptcy Institute seminar last weekend. Student Loan Bankruptcy Law Even though bankruptcy law is federal law, it is not the same everywhere. Federal courts are divided into Circuits.  I am in the 6th, Michigan, which also includes Ohio, Kentucky… Continue Reading